Gen Singh: Indian army is toothless

Gen. Singh : Indian Army is toothless

ndia’s tank fleet lacks ammunition, its air defences are “97% obsolete” and its elite forces need essential weapons, the country’s army chief wrote in an explosive letter leaked yesterday.
The letter to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh dated March 12 - widely reported by the Indian media - lists shortcomings of the armed forces in embarrassing detail in a serious blow to the government and the Asian giant’s military prestige.
Its publication also ups the stakes in a public battle between army chief General V K Singh and the government which began with a dispute over Singh’s retirement earlier this year.
“The state of the major (fighting) arms ie; mechanised forces, artillery, air defence, infantry and special forces, as well as the engineers and signals, is indeed alarming,” Singh wrote in the letter.
The army’s entire tank fleet is “devoid of critical ammunition to defeat enemy tanks,” while the air defence system is “97% obsolete and it doesn’t give the deemed confidence to protect... from the air,” he wrote.
The infantry is crippled with “deficiencies” and lacks night fighting equipment, while the elite special forces are “woefully short” of “essential weapons.”
Earlier this week Singh told The Hindu newspaper that he had informed Defence Minister A KAntony of a $2.8mn bribe offered to him in 2010, leading to questions as to why the government had not ordered an inquiry.
Antony has since scrambled to quell the controversy and has ordered a probe by the Central Bureau of Investigation. He also attempted to shift the blame to General Singh, saying he had not made a written complaint.
Speaking amid an uproar in parliament over the leaked letter, Antony said that the government had made efforts to ensure transparency in India’s notoriously corrupt defence procurement processes.
“We have equally taken care to speed up the modernisation of the armed forces. By doing that only we can assure national security and we can protect every inch of our motherland,” he told lawmakers.
Antony confirmed the existence of the letter and said it should not have been made public. Politicians from all parties reacted angrily and some called for the army chief’s resignation if he was found to be behind the leak.
“The government is determined to do all that is needed to continue to assure the safety and security of India,” Antony told parliament. “Publishing secret documents will not help the nation.”
In a rare show of unity, opposition parties rallied around the government, a sign of concerns about the army chief’s habit of challenging his civilian masters.
India remains concerned over China’s military build-up along the countries’ disputed border - the trigger for a brief war between the Asian giants in 1962 - and faces Pakistan to its west.
In the letter to the prime minister, General Singh reportedly blames the slow procurement process and lack of urgency among bureaucrats for the “hollowness” of the 1.13mn-strong military, the fourth largest in the world.
Senior opposition Bharatiya Janata Party leader Arun Jaitley complained of the “alarming situation” in which “letters which are otherwise intended to be secret and meant to be kept secret find there way into the media.”
“The fact that they can be leaked and come into the public domain itself is a matter of serious concern,” he told parliament.
Communist Party of India (Marxist)’s Sitaram Yechury, Janata Dal-United (JD-U) leader Shivanand Tiwari and several other opposition leaders also agreed that public debate on the issue was a serious concern.
“We are happy with the assurance... the information appearing in the media is a matter of utmost concern,” Yechury said.
The letter is likely to lead to a further deterioration in relations between General Singh and his civilian bosses.
The army chief, who faces mandatory retirement this May at the age of 62, was angered after losing a bid to stay in office an extra year by changing his birth date registered in army records. He claimed the birth date was wrongly recorded.
His complaints of poor equipment and operational difficulties also run contrary to government defence spending announcements and recent studies showing India as the world’s biggest military hardware importer.
The government this month announced a 17% rise in defence spending to $40bn in its budget for 2012/13 - following a 12% increase in the previous budget.
Between 2007 and 2011, India overtook China to be the biggest arms importer, accounting for 10% of the global arms market, according to recent data from the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI).
India’s military is also negotiating to acquire a slew of new equipment from combat aircraft to submarines and artillery.
It is currently finalising a deal with France’s Dassault Aviation to buy 126 Rafale fighter jets in a contract worth an estimated $12bn.